Hollywood has a long history of building films from video games, and it’s certainly not a stellar one. Taking characters and stories with huge existing fanbases should equal an easy win when it comes to throwing them on the big screen, but it’s rarely ever a successful mix. More often than not, the end result is a film that doesn’t do enough justice to the source material for fans, while also being too niche for wider audiences to get into. The latest to try his hand at breaking the mould this week is Sonic the Hedgehog, the infamous blue blur that has been synonymous with gaming for almost 30 years. Looking to bank on the somewhat surprise success of Pokémon: Detective Pikachu last year, Sonic aims to hit that nostalgic goldmine with a new origin story, big personalities and some flashy CGI. When all is said and done, Sonic the Hedgehog doesn’t quite run rings around the competition, though there is just enough there for him to get you walking, if maybe not running, to the cinemas.
The live-action adaptation is set largely in Green Hills, a fictional small town in rural California. Living secretly in the woods of the town is the titular blue hedgehog, having been stranded for years following a speedy (and somewhat bizarre) opening scene. Sonic (Ben Schwartz) claims to be ‘living his best life’ as he zips around town unseen, however it’s quickly clear that his many years in hiding have taken a toll. To combat his loneliness, he keeps close tabs on the town’s sheriff Tom Wachowski (James Marsden) and wife Maddie (Tika Sumpter) who – unknown to them – are his closest friends on Earth. Before too long, Sonic accidentally attracts the attention of the power-crazed scientist Dr Robotnik (Jim Carrey), spurring an unlikely road trip as Sonic and the sheriff try to outrun the mad doctor. The story is even more cliché than it sounds, with the heroes running through bar fights, car chases and a whole lot of bro talk along the way. It’s a very safe and predictable plot, which makes sense overall as you quickly realise that the film has a pretty specific target audience. Where Detective Pikachu managed to walk the line between pleasing both long-time fans and younger moviegoers, Sonic instead chooses to lean heavily into (not so) current pop-culture trends and jokes with just hints of nostalgia scattered throughout. Sonic is fundamentally the same character that we all remember, it’s just that now he pokes fun at Vin Diesel and spends a little too much time doing the floss.
Spicing up the hedgehog’s attitude and style isn’t necessarily a bad thing, and it certainly helps given that he’s the centre of attention for just about the entire length of the adventure. Sonic blitzes through jokes and dialogue like a kid on a sugar rush, with his loud and scattered delivery the polar opposite of Ryan Reynold’s more restrained and subtle performance as Pikachu last year. It all fits with the general Sonic vibe however, and his big personality blends with the zany action and plot spilling out around him. James Marsden’s character does fine with what he’s given as Sonic’s partner, however it’s a role built solely to prop up and guide Sonic to his next punchline or destination. The same can be said for many of the remaining supporting cast, who again offer up good performances despite the titular hero continuing to steal the spotlight. The only character that truly manages to challenge the star is Jim Carrey’s Dr Robotnik, who quite frankly lifts the film far higher than it otherwise would have been. Robotnik has been Sonic’s arch nemesis for decades, and Carrey seems to revel in the role following a recent break from notable big-screen appearances. He brings his trademark manic style to the mad doctor, always teetering on the edge of insanity when on the hunt for Sonic, interacting with loyal right hand man Agent Stone (Lee Majdoub) or just turning in a bizarre two-minute dance sequence to the song “Where Evil Grows”. Robotnik is an old-fashioned, moustache-twirling villain that shouldn’t be nearly as interesting as the character Carrey manages to create, and his hits of madness are spread well throughout the film.
Also cropping up alongside the Doctor’s appearances are some of the film’s many action and CGI-heavy moments – each generally more explosive than the last. Everything from Sonic’s fur and quills through to Robotnik’s drones and gadgets have all been put seamlessly into the real world, allowing for some great and inventive scenes to come through. A solid example comes when we’re given Sonic’s point of view as he hits superspeed, watching as he moves through and plays with a world moving around him in slow motion. This is all in addition to the very successful ground-up redesign of the star hedgehog himself, following the now infamous initial preview of the film that tried to sell a human/hedgehog hybrid nightmare just last year. While the changes to Sonic ended up delaying the film quite a bit, they were definitely worth the wait given the result. In fact, the effects work is almost held back by its ties to real-world backgrounds, which add very little to the adventure as a whole. We’re given brief flashes at Sonic’s familiar, video game home which hopefully will be expanded on in the more-than-likely sequel down the line.
Sonic the Hedgehog is the latest challenger to attempt making the move from games to the big screen, and he manages to give it a solid swing. Sonic’s design and abilities have been handled with an amazing amount of care and detail, giving you enough to appreciate when his banter starts to dip. Pairing his large personality with Carrey’s diabolical villain really saves the film from growing stale, and Carrey gives his performance just the right amount of edge to be dark without turning off the younger audience. It’s this audience that will get the most from the movie, though long-time fans will appreciate the hero’s design and fleeting nostalgic nods scattered throughout the lackluster, paint-by-numbers story. It may not be the event that finally brings film and games together, but Sonic the Hedgehog is a good bit of fun with some decent action, setting quite a pace for those to come in the future.
Sonic the Hedgehog stars Ben Schwartz, Jim Carrey, James Marsden, Tika Sumpter, Lee Majdoub, Natasha Rothwell & Adam Pally – In cinemas now.